Anatomy, physiology and pathology of a State


A State and an animal body are two examples of very complex systems. They are both composed of units organized on different levels. Those units are required to efficiently cooperate for the wider system to survive. Given the similarities between the State and a - human - body, the second has already been used as an allegory to describe the first1,2.

     Here, I will apply definitions from biology and medicine as metaphors to concepts of politology. When describing a living being, both at microscopical or macroscopical level, three main aspects can be distinguished:
i) its anatomy, or how it is physically made; 
ii) its physiology, or how it works;
iii) its pathology, or how it gets disfunctional.

     All those aspects are directly interlinked and dependent on each other, bearing strict cause-effect relationships. On these basis, I am going to identify the correspondences between multiple organs and systems of a human body and the fundamental components of a modern State. I am going to analyze their parallelisms, into how they are structured and they absolve to precise functions. And I am going to review how they can be the focus of diseases. 

    So, would the development of a 'police State' be a case of autoimmunity? Or a tumor of the immune system?

     Is a 'credit choke' crisis an ischemia? Or a heart failure? Or renal failure?

     In future posts, I will follow logic in depicting a complex metaphors. I acknowledge that it can not be perfect because in several cases parallelisms would not fit. I will discuss case by case.




                                        Index

         Body organ                           State apparatus

1.      cells                                        people




4.      blood                                      money


5.      heart                                       trade


 6.      blood vessels                         jobs, cost of life, credit system


 7.      lungs                                      money investments, foreign capitals and funds


8.      kidneys                                  Central Banks, inflation/deflation


9.      digestive system                    refinement, production


10.    fat tissue                                welfare

11.    liver                                       healthcare


12.    immune system                     justice, police, military


13.    Th immune cells                   public opinion


14.    muscles                                  people's initiative

15.    bones                                     concept of society

16.    tendons                                  common values, national identity, language, attitudes


17.    brain cortex                           government, those who manipulates them

18.    lower brain                            burocracy

19.    peripheral nervous system    elections and laws



References

1: Spicci M. The body as metaphor: digestive bodies and political surgery in Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Medical Humanities 2007; 33:67-69.

2: Sălăvăstru A. Disease of the Body, Disease of the State: a Metaphor of Political Discourse in XVIth England (Thomas Starkey). Argumentum 2012; 10(1), 18-47.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On the nature of power – where it comes from, how it spirals out of control

Image
Power. That is the abstract concept behind the one of leadership, fundamental to understand the evolution of human sociality. The nature of power is elusive and yet fascinating.  Everyone wants power . There are the ones who want to rule, and they need power; the ones who strive to accomplish, and they need power; even the ones who just wish to live quiet and unnoticed, they need the power to have someone else manage responsibilities in their place. Any ambition has to be sustained by power. And power is in the first place the power to choose; who to be, what to do, how to act or even to not act at all. What is power? So many variables and just one word, then. What is power? How would you define it? ‘Power’ has many possible facets, depending on the contexts. In general, we can say that power is the capability to bend and shape specific aspects of reality according to one’s will. This is magnified when people work together – humans are a social ...
Read more

How to take on Russia via Syria - why did Russia become an obsession?

Image
The Syrian Civil War ending... and then what? from https://buffalonews.com/2018/04/17/ the-briefing-why-syria-matters/ In Syria, the battle for Idlib - until now occupied by terrorists affiliated and related to Al-Qaeda - is imminent. Other territories controlled by rebels - 'moderate' or not - are few and isolated. Kurds are negotiating with Assad and will likely see recognized part of the autonomy they ask, if Syria territorial integrity will be reconstituted. All in all, the war in Syria is coming to its conclusion - and the USA-led Coalition can't do much to hinder that, as we prefigured . So, is it almost done? Or do we have to expect other crisis and possibly escalations before we can call the conflict off? Of course, in a future perspective, one major issue will be Israel attitude - along with the ones of Saudi Arabia and Turkey on the backsides. Relationships between Israel and Syria will be difficult to normalize without finding a compromise over th...
Read more

The manipulation of society - how people are made to believe

Image
Our society is a complex system, people interconnected on multiple levels of interaction. It has to be somehow dynamic in order to match, reflect and contribute to progress. In fact, society evolves similar to how living species do – under environmental pressure. Like a building lying on shifting foundations, its walls moving along and adjusting their shape to remain intact, society continuously changes. All of those steps answer internal or external needs and opportunities. Looking at the West, how is the society evolving? What its needs, what the opportunities?     The needs can easily be declined in terms of money, power, influence, supremacy – progress costs, after all. New opportunities to fulfill those needs, and how the may be exploited, depend on the context. For instance, technological innovations can provide lots of surprises – like Internet has been an horizon of the events in respect to communications. We could talk about many different aspects – in part alrea...
Read more